Magazine

Is there a worldwide parking problem?

Parked cars

A revolution is required in our attitude to car parking, according to the author of a new book. He claims we are adrift in a "sea of asphalt" and calls on architects to design car parks which are more aesthetically pleasing and have less environmental impact.

There are an estimated 600 million cars in the world, a figure that's rapidly growing, especially in China and other "emerging markets".

They all need to park somewhere.

In the US, surface car parks take up land roughly about the size of Puerto Rico (which is 3,459 sq miles or 8,959 sq km), according to conservative estimates in a new book by Eran Ben-Joseph, professor of landscape architecture and planning at Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). He thinks the true figure could be up to 4,700 sq miles (12,170 sq km, larger than Jamaica or Qatar).

Land is plentiful in the US - except for some cities - and consequently parking lots take up huge amounts of space.

Shopping malls, cinemas, stadiums, factories and office complexes are surrounded by prairies of bitumen.

Many of them are deliberately designed for the busiest shopping day of the year, the day after Thanksgiving, which means they are often half-empty.

Aerial shot of a shopping mall parking lot in Marlborough, Massachusetts
Designed for those few days when it's full

Prof Ben-Joseph says: "These places are just surrounded by a sea of asphalt."

In Europe, Japan and in US cities like New York and Boston, where land is at a premium, multi-storey car parks - or "parking garages" - are the preferred option.

In his book, ReThinking a Lot, Prof Ben-Joseph argues car parks should be more "environmentally responsible" and "aesthetically pleasing".

So what could be done to improve them?

Better design

The 1111 Lincoln Road car park in Miami
This Miami car park by Herzog de Meuron is a rare example of beautiful design

Few multi-storey car parks are cultural assets, but these 10 examples of modernist architecture show there are occasions when architects excel themselves and create landmarks a city can be proud of.

Eric Kuhne, who designed the award-winning car park at Bluewater shopping centre, just outside London , said there was no excuse for drab parking lots, which he described as "insidious".

The unused parking lot at the Dutchess Mall in Fishkill, New York state
The car park at Dutchess Mall in Fishkill, New York, is largely unused

"At Bluewater there are two trees for every three cars and we chose trees which give a blindingly white blossom in the spring and iridescent leaves in the fall. The car parks become a sea of colour," said Mr Kuhne, who was born in the US but is now based in London.

Mr Kuhne says: "Too often parking lot design is perfunctory and ignominious when it could restore pageantry to our great cities."

He says they should be designed in such a way that they "honour the heroic routine" of driving, working and shopping.

Using new technology

In his book Prof Ben-Joseph says when the automobile was first invented they were usually parked by the kerb like the horses and wagons they would eventually replace.

The world's first parking lot is believed to have been built in 1917 in Los Angeles by a young Italian immigrant, Andrew Pansini.

The following year the La Salle Hotel in Chicago built the first parking garage on multiple levels.

Over the years there have been a number of developments - underground car parks, pay and display machines and most recently the advent of paying by mobile phone.

The first automated car parks were developed in the US in the 1920s.

But robotic car parks really took off in Japan in the 1970s, especially in Tokyo which suffers from an acute shortage of land and needed to maximise the number of cars which could be stored at any one time.

The Cube, an office and apartment development in Birmingham, opened in 2010 and has installed an automated parking system which allows cars to "park themselves".

The robotics system is expensive - around £2m - but it allows for more cars to be crammed in.

New technology is also being used to try to solve the problem of driving around looking for a parking space.

A British company, Deteq, has invented a system of smart sensors which can be installed in car parks to enable the operators to know how many spaces they had and which times of day were most popular.

The managing director of Brighton-based Deteq, Adrian Bone, said: "We've also developed an app which would allow the motorist to find out where the nearest parking spaces were."

Reducing environmental impact

Lot 59 at Arizona State University
Solar panels at Arizona State University could power 550 homes

It has been known for years that asphalt soaking up the sun's rays contributes to the "urban heat island" phenomena which makes cities warmer than surrounding rural areas.

Now efforts are under way to harness that energy.

One such project is in Tempe, Arizona.

The so-called Lot 59 project has seen a five-acre parking lot at the Arizona State University's Sun Devils gridiron stadium covered with giant solar panels, which can produce 2.2 megawatts of electricity annually - enough to power 550 homes.

Bob Boscamp, one of the founders of the company behind the recently-unveiled Power Parasol, said the design allows 23% of the light to get through, creating a "dappled" effect for motorists.

Another Arizona company is pioneering the use of "nano-engineered colour coatings" on asphalt parking lots.

Sheri Roese, founder and CEO of Emerald Cities Cool Pavement, says: "Who decided that all roads and parking lots should be black?"

"It was the unintended consequence of advancement in the transportation industry since the 1800s, minus an understanding of how colour impacts the environment.

"Now we know hot black asphalt is contributing to urban heat."

The new coating was applied to a school parking lot in Phoenix .

Meanwhile scientists at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in California are working on developing reflective asphalt , which if used on parking lots could significantly reduce the amount of heat which is absorbed.

Another project which is in its early days, as reported recently in the Boston Business Journal , is a plan to create energy by heating water running in pipes beneath asphalt parking lots.

Mike Hulen, the founder of Novotech, the Massachusetts company behind it, has tried it out at a test site in Arizona and told the BBC: "Asphalt is a perfect black body and the idea is to trap the heat in it and remove it."

He has a number of patents pending in the field and is on the look-out for funding for the project.

The parking lot at Robert Duffy School in Arizona painted with reflective asphalt
Covering black asphalt with a light coloured coating reduces heat absorption

Using the space above

The fate of one of Britain's most iconic car parks is symptomatic of a new architectural trend.

The Trinity Square car park in Gateshead, Tyneside, made an infamous cameo appearance in the cult film Get Carter, starring Michael Caine.

Trinity Square car park in Gateshead

Built in the 1960s, it hulked over the centre of the town for years, but was eventually demolished in 2010 and is being replaced by a massive new development.

The £150m redevelopment , which will include a supermarket and accommodation for the nearby Northumbria University, is designed with a 700-space underground car park.

Underground car parks or car parks with buildings on top of them gobble up less land and can be designed to reduce environmental impact.

Having a party in the lot

Tailgating party in the parking lot at Kansas City Chiefs stadium
Tailgating culture is a US tradition and Kansas City Chiefs are proud of the parties in their parking lot

In the US "tailgating" is a way of using car parks for cooking and partying before sporting events.

The Kansas City Chiefs, an American football team, are proud of the tailgating facilities at their Arrowhead Stadium, which can accommodate 25,000 cars and opens three-and-a-half hours before games kick off.

Chiefs president Mark Donovan told the BBC: "There is nothing quite like the tradition of tailgating at Arrowhead on game day.

"Several hours before the game, our parking lots are filled with fans who share great Kansas City barbecue and their passion for the Chiefs.

"Every family or groups of friends has its own style and menu, ranging from lobster to slow-smoked ribs to cheeseburgers on the grill."

Digging up car parks

Digging up the parking lot of the Disjecta arts centre's parking lot in Portland, Oregon
Depaving - digging up asphalt parking lots and replacing it with greenery - has become all the rage in Portland, Oregon

Some activists are determined to roll back the expansion of asphalt and have starting digging up parking lots.

Depave, a group based in Portland, Oregon, has persuaded an increasing number of schools, theatres and other institutions to dig up part, or all, of their parking lots.

Depave's marketing co-ordinator, Eric Rosewall, told the BBC: "The community depaving events that our group puts on are grand demonstrations meant to bring neighborhoods together around a site, to get residents involved in the rebirth of the new greenspace.

"Beyond the community building and educational aspects that are the main goals of these events, depaving creates permeable space that allows stormwater to infiltrate on-site instead of flowing into storm sewers and eventually streams, rivers, and the ocean - carrying surface pollutants like oil from cars with it."

Tell us what you think about this tool. Was it easy to use? Did it help your understanding of the piece? Give us your feedback using this form .

Related Internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites